Someone asked me recently why I’m opposed to AI writing in blogs and newsletters but I’m fine
with it for generating code. This is my attempt to answer that question. I’m fine with AI
coding because no one cares what the code actually looks like except for other software
engineers. The customers don’t care. The managers don’t care. They want the software to work.
They want it to look good and be fast and reliable. They don’t care how the sausage is
made.
If you live on Planet Earth and you are at all connected to software you've
probably tried out vibe coding, ie: using an AI tool to write software for
you. As someone who's been writing software for close to four decades I've seen
code automation tools come and go. Believe it or not, people used to talk about
Visual Basic in the same breathless tones of today's vibe coding tools. The
outcome has always been the same: new tech is useful in some context but never
lives up to the hype. The tricky part is always figuring out what it's good at
and what it isn't. I believe these AI tools will go the same way; but hey,
maybe this time it's different. I can't talk about what I haven't experienced,
so I tried experiments this week. Here's what I learned.
True high level Artificial Intelligence, the kind we read about in novels and hear crazy stories about from futurists, won't be like the movies. There won't be a Her that we fall in love with. There won't be a HAL 9000 who turns against us. When we finally build a true self-learning AI, it won't be anything at all like a human intelligence. This shouldn't be a surprise. We have half a century of results to show this is true.